Free reading sample

Begin UNSOLVED

An Alex Harlan novel by R. L. Chauncey

The prologue, Chapter One, and part of Chapter Two.

Copyright © 2026 R. L. Chauncey. All rights reserved.

PROLOGUE — Emily Voss

Macon, Georgia — October 2009

The moon gave just enough light to separate the trees from the sky. Emily Voss stumbled through wet pine straw and red clay while something tightened painfully around her wrists each time he pulled her forward. The highway was close. That was the worst part. Cars still passed beyond the woods often enough that she could hear tires on wet pavement between the trees.

Once, headlights flashed through the brush ahead, pale and broken against the trunks, and hope hit hard enough to make her try to scream through the tape across her mouth. The sound barely escaped. Then the car was gone.

He kept moving.

He wasn’t dragging her violently, and she wasn’t struggling. He was simply taking her somewhere.

Emily tried to plant her knees and stop him. Clay slid beneath her weight. One shoe caught against a root before slipping loose again. Pain shot through both shoulders as the line around her wrists drew tighter. She twisted, trying to look behind her. A gloved hand settled against her upper arm and redirected her forward.

No shove.

No blow.

He simply turned her where he wanted her to go. Emily tried to scream again.

Nothing useful came through the tape.

If he had shouted at her, she might have understood something.

Anger.

Panic.

Fear.

Anything.

Instead, he moved without speaking. Wet leaves stuck to her knees each time she fell. Dirt smeared one side of her face. Her breathing became ragged behind the tape.

He never hurried.

That frightened her more than anything else. They reached a small clearing.

He stopped.

Emily felt hope rise so quickly that her knees almost gave way. Then he pulled her away from it. Back through the trees. She did not understand why. A few minutes later they stopped again, this time near enough to the highway that the sound of a passing car seemed almost directly beyond the brush.

He stood still.

Listening.

Emily tried to make noise.

He moved again.

The second place disappeared behind them.

Her wrists burned.

Her shoulders ached.

She could no longer tell how far they had walked. Only that he kept changing direction whenever the woods opened too much or the road came too near.

Another vehicle passed.

Emily forced sound into the tape.

Nothing.

He stopped completely.

For one impossible second she thought he had heard her. Instead, he stood behind her, motionless, facing toward the highway.

The tires faded.

The road became quiet. Then he started moving again. A third clearing appeared between the trees. Smaller than the others.

Uneven.

Barely open to the sky. He brought her into the center and released her. Emily fell hard onto one shoulder. Wet earth pressed cold against her cheek. She moved immediately, trying to get her legs beneath her.

He let her.

That terrified her.

She rolled partly onto her back and finally saw enough of him to assemble fragments.

Dark coat.

Dark pants.

Gloves.

Average height, maybe.

Nothing she could hold onto.

Nothing she could imagine describing afterward.

He crouched in front of her. For a moment they were almost eye level. Emily tried to speak through the tape.

Tried to beg.

Tried to make him look at her.

He did.

His face showed no anger.

No urgency.

He seemed to be studying her.

Then he spoke.

“I’m sorry, Emily.”

His voice was calm.

Almost gentle.

“You’re just… perfect.”

Emily shook her head violently. Tears blurred one eye. She dragged herself backward through the mud with her heels. He moved behind her. She felt the change before she understood it.

Then the clothesline touched her throat. Everything inside her erupted. She twisted hard enough to roll sideways, trying to force her chin down, trying to get anything between the line and her neck before it tightened. Her bound hands jerked uselessly behind her. The line settled into place.

Moved once.

Then tightened.

Emily tried to inhale.

Nothing came.

Panic exploded through her chest. Her legs kicked against the ground, throwing mud and leaves behind her. She twisted, tried to roll, tried to make space between the line and her throat. He moved with her.

The pressure stayed.

The tape across her mouth trapped the sounds she tried to make. Her body kept trying anyway. She rolled partly onto one shoulder. Her knees dug into the softened ground before slipping out again. Her hands pulled uselessly against the bindings behind her back.

The pressure increased.

Her vision shifted.

The trees seemed to tilt. She heard herself making sounds now.

Thin.

Broken.

Nothing like words.

He said nothing.

Emily drove backward, trying to knock him off balance. He shifted with her. The line never loosened. A thought came through the panic. He knows how to do this.

She tried again.

Harder.

Nothing changed.

Her body fought anyway. Her heels carved broken trenches through the wet clay. Leaves stuck to her face. Her fingers opened and closed behind her. Darkness crowded inward at the edges of her vision.

She tried to pull another breath.

Couldn’t.

Tried again.

The woods blurred.

Movement became harder.

Her legs still kicked, but without the same force. Her body seemed to lose track of what she was asking it to do. A truck passed on the highway. Close enough that she could hear water hissing beneath its tires.

Emily heard it.

For a moment, everything inside her reached toward that sound. Then it moved away. Her legs kicked once.

Again.

The second movement was weaker. After that, nothing happened when she tried.

The pressure remained.

He held the line after Emily stopped moving.

Several seconds passed.

Then several more.

Finally, the pressure released. Her body settled into the mud. He remained behind her.

Still.

Listening.

One gloved hand moved to the side of her neck. He held it there.

Waited.

Then removed it.

For several seconds he did nothing. The highway continued beyond the trees.

A car passed.

Then another.

He stood.

Emily lay partly on one shoulder where she had fallen.

He moved her.

One arm first.

Then the other.

He placed them alongside her body.

Stepped back.

Looked.

Moved one again.

He straightened her shoulders. Turned her head slightly toward the open section of sky above the clearing. Her legs were next. He brought them closer together. One shoe had collected leaves against the heel.

He brushed them away. Mud covered the knees of her jeans. Her hair lay partly across her face. He moved it behind her shoulder. Then he stepped back again.

Looked.

Waited.

The camera came from inside his coat.

Polaroid.

Older model.

He raised it toward her.

Paused.

Moved half a step to the left.

Click.

The sound was small in the clearing. He lowered the camera and waited.

The photograph emerged.

He held it by one edge while the image began to appear. He looked toward Emily again.

Raised the camera.

Click.

A second photograph.

He waited for it.

Then a third.

Click.

Three.

He put the camera away. The photographs went inside his coat. His hand returned holding a small spiral notebook. The cover was worn.

He opened it.

Wrote something.

Stopped.

Looked toward Emily.

Wrote again.

Then closed the notebook and returned it to his coat. He stood over her for several seconds.

No movement from Emily.

Nothing from the woods.

He turned away.

Instead of taking the same path back toward the highway, he moved toward the edge of the clearing where exposed roots broke through the soil. His steps shifted from mud to firmer ground. Then from roots to pine straw. The clothesline remained around Emily’s neck. He disappeared between the trees.

A minute later, another car passed on Highway 18. Its headlights moved briefly through the branches.

Then darkness returned.

Emily remained in the clearing. Broken tracks cut through the mud near her heels. Leaves clung to one side of her face. Above the trees, the moon remained visible through a narrow break in the clouds. Traffic continued beyond the woods.

CHAPTER ONE — The Unit

Alex Harlan reached Peachtree before sunrise and spent twenty minutes moving six blocks. Construction had narrowed three lanes to one near Midtown. Delivery trucks nosed toward loading docks while commuters crowded every opening they could find. A police officer stood in the intersection waving traffic around a concrete mixer that had stopped halfway through a turn. Alex moved with everybody else. His phone buzzed against the console.

Sarah.

He answered. “You’re early.”

“You called before briefing.”

“That’s because I know you.”

Her voice carried the tired edge of another night at Grady.

“Did you eat?”

“Yes.”

“You hesitated.”

“I was deciding how detailed an answer you wanted.”

“You were deciding whether to lie.”

“That too.”

She laughed.

He could hear traffic behind her, then the hollow change in sound as she entered the parking garage.

“You heading home?” he asked.

“Eventually.”

“Long night?”

“Normal.”

“That bad?”

“Normal.”

A line of cars moved forward. Alex gained half a block before brake lights stopped him again.

Sarah said, “You nervous?”

“No.”

“That came too fast.”

“It was true.”

“You already sizing everybody up?”

“I haven’t met most of them.”

“You don’t need to.”

“That sounds judgmental.”

“It’s observational.”

“Profiler talk.”

“Human talk.”

A horn sounded behind Alex. He looked in the mirror. The driver in the pickup behind him raised both hands as though Alex personally controlled Atlanta traffic.

Sarah said, “Well, go save Georgia from itself.”

“That seems ambitious.”

“You federal people like ambition.”

“We prefer achievable objectives.”

“You prefer government shoes, behavioral terminology, and emotionally unavailable haircuts.”

“I do not have a federal haircut.”

“You absolutely have a federal haircut.”

Alex smiled. “Drive safe.”

“You too.”

The call ended.

Traffic moved again.

Alex reached the federal building a little before seven and pulled into the secured lot.

The folder on the passenger seat carried a printed label:

METRO ATLANTA VIOLENT OFFENDER TASK FORCE

INITIAL COORDINATION MATERIALS

He picked it up and went inside. Security checked his credentials and waved him through. The elevator opened on the third floor. The task force had taken over converted administrative space.

Temporary partitions divided the bullpen badly enough that conversations carried through them. Phones rang across several desks. Printers ran almost continuously. Analysts moved between workstations carrying folders, evidence summaries, and printed surveillance stills. A city map covered most of one wall. Another held three photographs beneath separate case headings.

LAKE LANIER — DROWNING

METRO ATLANTA — OVERDOSE

FULTON COUNTY — SUICIDE

No arrows connected them.

That was the first thing Alex noticed. The second was the television. A local morning program was running with the sound low. A man stood outside a courthouse speaking into a handheld microphone while photographs of the three dead appeared beside him. The lower-third identified him.

PRESTON FLOYD

INVESTIGATIVE CORRESPONDENT

Someone near the television raised the volume. Preston’s voice carried across the bullpen.

“Three families have been told three different versions of the same thing: the investigation is over. Maybe those conclusions are right. Maybe every one of them is right. But if law enforcement is reviewing these deaths again, then somebody found a reason to ask another question.”

The anchor interrupted from the studio. “Are you suggesting these deaths are connected?”

“No.”

The answer came immediately.

“I’m suggesting dead people deserve better than having everyone race toward the most dramatic explanation or the most convenient one. If they’re connected, prove it. If they aren’t, prove that too. But stop treating the families like asking questions is an inconvenience.”

An APD detective near the television muttered, “There’s Floyd.”

Another answered, “He’s been on this since yesterday.”

Preston continued. “The drowning victim’s sister has asked for an independent review for eight months. The overdose victim’s father says he still hasn’t received answers about the timeline. The third family has declined to speak publicly, and frankly, people ought to respect that.”

The anchor tried again. “But there are reports of a possible serial offender.”

“There are reports that reporters are using the phrase serial offender.”

A few people in the bullpen laughed.

Preston did not. “There is no publicly established serial case. There are three dead people. Start there.”

A woman near the center operations table picked up the remote and muted the television.

GBI badge.

Mid-forties.

Dark blazer over rolled sleeves. She looked directly at Alex.

“Alex Harlan.”

“Cartwright.”

Her eyes moved over him once.

“I asked Quantico for one behavioral specialist. They sent two.”

“We’ll try not to multiply.”

The corner of her mouth moved.

Almost.

“Set up wherever. Briefing in twenty.”

She was already turning away. Alex claimed a desk near the edge of the bullpen and put down his bag. A man in a dark GBI polo approached carrying two cups of coffee.

“Ramirez. Georgia Bureau. Assigned to help you survive Atlanta.”

“Harlan.”

Ramirez handed him one of the cups. Alex looked at it. “You drink coffee?”

“Yes.”

“Then technically that qualifies.”

Alex took it.

Ramirez nodded toward the muted television. Preston Floyd was still talking beneath captions. “You know him?”

“No.”

“You will.”

“That a warning?”

“Depends which side of a microphone you’re standing on.”

Alex looked toward the screen. Preston had turned toward a photograph of the Lake Lanier victim.

The caption beneath him read:

FAMILIES DEMAND ANSWERS IN CLOSED DEATH CASES

“He always like that?” Alex asked.

“Floyd?”

“Yes.”

Ramirez took a drink. “He gets louder when he thinks somebody without a voice is getting buried under procedure.”

“That happen often?”

“You work for the federal government. You tell me.”

Alex smiled.

Ramirez nodded toward him. “Georgia originally?”

“Macon.”

Recognition crossed his face.

“You’re one of those.”

“One of what?”

“People who name Georgia cities instead of saying ‘south of Atlanta.’”

“That bothers you?”

“No. Gives me hope.”

A printer near the far wall started making a grinding noise. An APD detective walked past and struck the side panel with the heel of his hand. The printer immediately resumed. Ramirez pointed toward it.

“Last FBI guy filed a maintenance request.”

“What happened?”

“They sent him to Tennessee.”

Alex looked toward him. “That connected?”

“Absolutely not.”

Near the windows, a man stood reading a file. Gray at the temples.

Suit jacket open.

Still enough that the movement around him became more noticeable by comparison.

Elias Thorne.

Alex knew him.

Not well enough to call him a friend.

Well enough to know how rooms reacted to him. A detective approached with a question.

Elias listened.

Answered quietly.

The detective nodded and walked away. Another investigator stepped in almost immediately. Ramirez followed Alex’s attention.

“Your other Quantico gift.”

“I know him.”

“Everybody knows him.”

“That’s not the same thing.”

“No,” Ramirez said. “It isn’t.”

Cartwright’s voice carried across the bullpen.

“Conference room.”

Ramirez picked up his coffee. “There goes breakfast.”

“This was breakfast?”

“Don’t judge me.”

The conference room held representatives from enough agencies that nobody had bothered trying to arrange the seating by jurisdiction.

Atlanta Police.

Fulton County.

Cobb County.

GBI.

Federal support.

A prosecutor from Fulton.

Two analysts.

One representative from the medical examiner’s office. Elias took a chair near the wall. Alex sat beside Ramirez near the middle of the table.

Cartwright remained standing. “Let’s establish what this is before somebody outside this room establishes it for us.”

She pointed toward the first photograph on the wall.

“Three deaths are under coordinated review.”

The Lake Lanier drowning.

A metro-area overdose.

A death previously classified as suicide.

“Different jurisdictions. Different investigative histories. Different causes and manners.”

A Fulton detective leaned back. “Which is why half of us are here because somebody on television said serial killer.”

Cartwright looked toward the muted television visible through the conference-room glass. Preston Floyd remained on-screen.

“No,” she said. “We’re here because enough specific questions survived the original investigations that command authorized comparison.”

The detective gestured toward the wall. “We still don’t have common victimology.”

“Correct.”

“Common geography?”

“Not enough to matter yet.”

“Forensics?”

“None established across all three.”

He spread his hands.

“Then what are we comparing?”

Cartwright looked toward Alex. “Harlan.”

Several people turned.

Alex opened the packet in front of him. “I’d start with the files.”

The detective frowned. “We have the files.”

“You have the conclusions.”

“That distinction sounds expensive.”

Ramirez looked down at his coffee.

Alex continued. “The drowning was ruled accidental.”

“Yes.”

“The overdose was ruled accidental.”

“Yes.”

“The suicide was ruled suicide.”

“Yes.”

“Those classifications may all survive review.”

The detective waited.

Alex looked at the three photographs. “What specific repeating features caused somebody to pull all three files?”

Cartwright answered. “Sequence.”

She moved to the board.

“Each victim was last known alive without any reported acute crisis.”

She pointed to the drowning.

“Witness accounts disagree about his condition and movements before he entered the water.”

The overdose.

“Timeline discrepancies exist between last confirmed contact, estimated ingestion, and discovery.”

The suicide.

“Behavioral information collected after death did not align cleanly with some witness accounts obtained during the initial investigation.”

The prosecutor spoke.

“None of that establishes homicide.”

“No,” Alex said.

“Or a common offender.”

“No.”

“Then what does it establish?”

“That the files contain unresolved questions.”

The prosecutor nodded.

“Fine.”

A Cobb investigator tapped the suicide photograph with his pen.

“This one had motive context.”

Alex looked over. “For whom?”

The investigator hesitated. “Her.”

“For suicide?”

“Yes.”

“What evidence?”

“Relationship collapse. Financial stress. Prior statements.”

“Direct suicidal statements?”

“Not exactly.”

“Prior attempt?”

“No.”

“Note?”

“No.”

The investigator’s expression hardened.

“You trying to relitigate the case from a summary?”

“No. I’m trying to establish what the summary actually establishes.”

Cartwright let the exchange end there. She pointed toward the board. “This unit does not reopen all three cases today.”

She wrote:

REVIEW

Beneath the photographs.

“We compare.”

Then:

SEQUENCE

“Last confirmed normal activity.”

LOCATION

“Where the person was last reliably placed.”

CONTACT

“Who interacted with them.”

ACCESS

“Who could reach them.”

EVIDENCE

“What survived.”

CONTRADICTIONS

“What does not fit the final explanation.”

Alex watched the board fill.

No theory section.

Good.

Cartwright capped the marker. “Nobody loses jurisdiction. Nobody surrenders case ownership. We exchange what matters before media pressure turns this into something the evidence doesn’t support.”

The speakerphone lit.

Washington.

Cartwright answered.

A deputy director joined without introduction.

“Where are we?”

“Initial comparison.”

“Media is already ahead of you.”

Ramirez muttered, “That’s what they’re for.”

Alex heard him.

Cartwright probably did too.

She ignored it.

The deputy director continued. “We need consistent messaging.”

“We need consistent facts.”

“You know what I mean.”

“Yes.”

“What can we say?”

“That three previously completed investigations are undergoing coordinated review. No common offender has been established.”

“Serial connection?”

“Not established.”

“Possible?”

Cartwright looked around the room. “Anything is possible before you examine it. That doesn’t make it useful language.”

The Fulton lieutenant lowered his eyes to hide a smile. The call lasted another two minutes.

Coordination.

Visibility.

Public confidence.

Then it ended.

Ramirez looked at the speakerphone. “Leadership has returned safely from combat.”

That got a few tired laughs. Cartwright pointed toward him.

“You volunteering for media?”

“No.”

“Then stop auditioning.”

The room broke.

Investigators carried files back into the bullpen. Alex remained seated long enough to look at the three photographs again.

Drowning.

Overdose.

Suicide.

Elias stood from the chair near the wall. Alex looked toward him. “Anything?”

Elias glanced at the photographs. “Too early.”

“That’s encouraging.”

“It should be.”

Elias picked up his file.

Alex asked, “You see a connection?”

“No.”

“Nothing?”

“I see three investigations being compared.”

“That’s it?”

“For now.”

He walked toward the door. Ramirez waited until Elias was gone.

“That man could make a weather forecast sound classified.”

Alex stood. “He’s careful.”

“That what you call it?”

“What do you call it?”

Ramirez considered the question. “Expensive silence.”

They returned to the bullpen. The arguments from the conference room followed them out. They just became smaller. Two APD detectives stood beside the central map discussing whether an old witness needed to be reinterviewed. A Fulton investigator argued with an analyst over missing timestamps.

Someone at the far printer asked where three pages of an autopsy supplement had gone. The television remained muted. Preston Floyd had been replaced by weather. Alex opened the first three case summaries at an empty workstation beside the evidence wall. The Lake Lanier file came first.

Male.

Forty-one.

Recovered from the water near a public access area.

Accidental drowning.

Toxicology showed alcohol but not enough to explain everything by itself. Two witnesses remembered him drinking. One remembered him leaving alone. Another thought someone had been with him near the parking area but could not provide a useful description.

No defensive injuries.

No clear evidence of assault.

No property theft identified.

Alex marked the page.

WITNESS — POSSIBLE SECOND PERSON / LOW CONFIDENCE

He moved on.

The overdose.

Male.

Thirty-six.

Found in an apartment.

Drug toxicity established.

No forced entry.

No obvious struggle.

A neighbor placed him alive later than the initial timeline comfortably allowed. Phone activity complicated the window further.

Nothing excluded accidental overdose.

Nothing in the summary explained the discrepancy either.

Alex wrote:

TIMELINE — VERIFY ORIGINAL SOURCES

The third file was the suicide.

Female.

Thirty-nine.

Found at home.

Death investigation completed.

No indication of forced entry.

No known witness to the death itself.

Recent relationship problems.

Financial stress.

Friends divided sharply afterward over whether the death surprised them. One described her as depressed. Another said she had been making plans for the following month. Neither statement proved anything. Alex closed the file.

Ramirez appeared beside him. “You making friends?”

“Not yet.”

“Good. They’re expensive.”

He looked at the notes.

“What do you have?”

“Three reasons to read the complete files.”

“That sounds disappointing.”

“It should.”

Ramirez pulled over a chair. “Want to know what everybody else has?”

“Yes.”

“Opinions.”

“Those come free.”

“Exactly.”

He nodded toward the drowning.

“Fulton thinks that one is strongest.”

“Why?”

“Witness inconsistency.”

“The overdose?”

“APD thinks the timeline is bad enough to revisit.”

“And the suicide?”

“Half the room wants it off the wall.”

“Why?”

“They think it makes the whole review look like pattern shopping.”

Alex looked at the photograph. “That’s a legitimate concern.”

Ramirez glanced over. “You agreeing with them?”

“I’m saying we should be able to remove it if the facts don’t support keeping it.”

“That will disappoint television.”

Alex looked toward the muted screen. “Television will survive.”

As though summoned, Preston Floyd appeared again. This time he stood outside the federal building. LIVE was displayed in the corner.

Ramirez laughed once. “There he is.”

Someone turned up the volume. Preston was speaking to another reporter.

“No, I don’t think the public needs investigators pretending certainty they don’t have.”

A microphone shifted closer.

“Do you believe the task force was formed because earlier agencies failed?”

“I believe three families were told their cases were finished, and now those cases are being looked at again. That makes asking what was missed a fair question.”

“Does that mean you believe police mishandled them?”

“No. It means I’m not going to insult the victims by deciding that before the records are reviewed.”

The reporter pressed.

“But you’ve been critical of the original investigations.”

“I’ve been critical of people treating closed as the same word as correct.”

Across the bullpen, a detective said, “That’s cute.”

Preston continued. “If the original investigators got every one of these right, say so when the review is finished. I’ll report it. But until then, Daniel Pritchard’s sister is still asking why two witness statements never matched. Robert Gaines’s father still wants an explanation for the missing hours in his son’s timeline. Those aren’t television props. Those are people who buried somebody.”

The room got quieter. Alex noticed Cartwright standing in her office doorway. She watched for several seconds. Then the anchor asked Preston whether the task force had agreed to speak with him.

“No.”

“Will you keep asking?”

“Yes.”

That got a small laugh from Ramirez. Preston looked directly into the camera.

“My position is simple. If somebody killed these people, find them. If nobody did, prove the original conclusions as well as the evidence allows. Either way, the dead deserve more than speculation.”

Cartwright muted the television again.

Nobody complained.

Ramirez looked toward Alex. “You see what I mean?”

“Yes.”

“He’s a pain in the ass.”

“He also didn’t say anything wrong.”

Ramirez pointed at him. “That’s what makes him dangerous.”

Cartwright walked past. “He’s dangerous when people give him bad information. Don’t.”

Ramirez raised his coffee. “Sound media policy.”

She kept walking.

Alex returned to the files. The first hour produced mostly verification work.

Original statements.

Dispatch times.

Medical examiner findings.

Supplemental interviews.

The three summaries had compressed each investigation enough that uncertainty sometimes looked cleaner than it had been. A young analyst arrived carrying a stack of dispatch records.

“Cartwright wants these cross-referenced against the original timelines.”

Alex looked at the stack. “Which timeline?”

She glanced toward the central board.

“Exactly.”

He took them.

Ramirez looked over. “Congratulations.”

“For what?”

“You officially have work.”

“I was afraid they brought me here for decoration.”

“Federal budgets aren’t that healthy.”

Alex started with the drowning. Different agencies had recorded time differently.

Dispatch timestamp.

Officer arrival.

Witness estimate.

Medical examiner estimate.

The gaps did not automatically mean anything. He wrote them down anyway. Across the room, Elias stood beside a detective reviewing another file. The detective was speaking quickly.

Elias was not.

Eventually the detective stopped. Elias pointed to something on the page. The detective looked at it.

Then nodded.

Ramirez followed Alex’s attention. “You know what bothers me about him?”

“You’ve mentioned several things.”

“Everybody goes to him already believing he knows the answer.”

“Does he?”

“That’s the problem.”

Alex looked toward Elias. “What problem?”

“He usually tells them they don’t have one.”

Alex smiled. “That sounds useful.”

“It’s deeply irritating.”

Cartwright stepped from her office. “Conference room in five.”

A groan moved through the bullpen.

She stopped.

“Good. You still have enough energy to complain.”

Ramirez stood. “She weaponizes morale.”

Alex gathered the three files. The second meeting was smaller.

Cartwright.

Alex.

Ramirez.

Elias.

A Fulton homicide lieutenant.

A Cobb investigator.

Two analysts.

The prosecutor.

The three case photographs remained on the wall. Cartwright pointed toward the drowning.

“Start over. What do we know?”

The Fulton lieutenant answered.

“Male. Forty-one. Recovered from Lake Lanier. Cause consistent with drowning. Manner ruled accidental.”

“Evidence supporting accident?”

“Alcohol. Recreational setting. No traumatic injury establishing assault. No evidence of restraint.”

“Anything inconsistent?”

“One witness possibly saw another person near him. Weak identification value.”

Cartwright looked toward Alex. “Anything else?”

“Timeline needs reconstruction from original sources.”

She nodded.

“Good.”

The analyst wrote:

DROWNING

CAUSE SUPPORTED

MANNER REVIEW

WITNESS DISCREPANCY

TIMELINE REBUILD

Cartwright moved to the overdose. APD had supplied the original toxicology. Drug toxicity was not in dispute. The question was timing.

A phone call.

A neighbor’s sighting.

An electronic transaction.

The intervals did not align cleanly.

“Could all of that still produce an accidental overdose?” Cartwright asked.

“Yes,” Alex said.

“Anything establishing administration by another person?”

“No.”

“Evidence someone else was present?”

“Not yet.”

The analyst wrote:

OVERDOSE

TOXICOLOGY SUPPORTED

TIMELINE DISCREPANCY

THIRD-PARTY PRESENCE NOT ESTABLISHED

Then the suicide.

The Cobb investigator spoke first.

“I still think this one comes off.”

Cartwright looked toward him. “Make the case.”

“No physical evidence of another person. No forced entry. No unexplained injury. Significant personal stress. Death scene consistent with the original finding.”

Alex asked, “Behavioral contradictions?”

“Friends disagree.”

“That’s common.”

“Exactly.”

The prosecutor looked toward Alex.

“You agree?”

“I agree disagreement among friends isn’t enough.”

Cartwright asked, “Anything else?”

Alex opened the file. “One witness reported future plans.”

The investigator shrugged. “People make plans and still kill themselves.”

“Yes.”

“Another described worsening depression.”

“Also possible.”

The investigator looked around the room. “So why is she here?”

Alex glanced at the photograph. “Because somebody pulled the file for a reason.”

“That isn’t evidence.”

“No.”

Cartwright looked toward the analyst. “What triggered inclusion?”

The analyst checked her notes. “An earlier regional review flagged a possible sequence similarity.”

“What similarity?”

“Contact gap before death.”

The room waited.

Cartwright frowned. “That’s it?”

“Primarily.”

Alex closed the file. “Then that’s not enough.”

The Cobb investigator leaned back.

“Thank you.”

Alex looked toward him. “That doesn’t mean the original conclusion is correct.”

The investigator’s expression changed again.

“It means we don’t keep this case in a comparative set because one timeline feature resembles two unrelated deaths.”

Cartwright nodded. “Separate it from the comparison board. Preserve the review request and document why.”

The analyst removed the photograph. For the first time that morning, the board became smaller. Ramirez looked toward Alex.

“That felt productive.”

“It was.”

“Because we eliminated work?”

“Yes.”

“I’m starting to like profiling.”

Cartwright moved to the remaining two cases. “Now tell me what repeats.”

Nobody answered immediately.

Alex looked at the board.

Drowning.

Overdose.

Two completely different mechanisms.

Different victims.

Different locations.

Different investigative histories.

“Nothing meaningful yet.”

The prosecutor nodded.

“That’s my read.”

The Fulton lieutenant looked dissatisfied.

Cartwright asked, “Then why keep comparing them?”

Alex answered. “Because each has a specific unresolved feature that could change the interpretation of the death.”

“Same feature?”

“No.”

“Same offender behavior?”

“Not established.”

“Same victimology?”

“No.”

“Same geography?”

“No.”

Cartwright nodded. “Good.”

Ramirez looked at her. “Good?”

“Yes. We have two files worth reviewing and no series.”

Elias spoke from near the wall. “That is progress.”

The room turned toward him.

The prosecutor asked, “You seeing anything else?”

Elias looked at the two photographs. “No.”

The prosecutor almost smiled.

“You flew down here for that?”

“I flew down here to determine whether there was something worth seeing.”

“And?”

“There may be.”

“Which is?”

Elias looked toward the files. “Where the original conclusions became assumptions.”

Alex watched him.

Cartwright asked, “Specific.”

Elias nodded toward the drowning. “The witness inconsistency was discounted because the death already looked accidental.”

Then the overdose.

“The timeline discrepancy was treated as peripheral because toxicology supplied an adequate mechanism.”

He looked around the room.

“Neither means the conclusion was wrong.”

The Fulton lieutenant asked, “Then what are you saying?”

“That once a case has an explanation, later information tends to be measured against the explanation instead of independently.”

Alex wrote the sentence down. Cartwright looked at the board. “Then that’s the assignment.”

She wrote:

DROWNING

REBUILD WITHOUT ASSUMING ACCIDENT

OVERDOSE

REBUILD WITHOUT ASSUMING SOLO INGESTION

She stepped back.

“No theory beyond that.”

The prosecutor nodded.

The meeting ended.

Back in the bullpen, the suicide file went into a separate review stack instead of returning to the main board. Alex watched the analyst remove its marker from the map. Ramirez came beside him.

“One down.”

“Not down.”

“You know what I mean.”

“It’s no longer in the comparative set.”

“You really do make sentences harder.”

“Sometimes they need to be.”

Ramirez looked toward the television. Preston Floyd had returned.

Muted again.

Beneath him:

TASK FORCE NARROWS INITIAL REVIEW

Ramirez pointed. “How does he know already?”

Alex looked toward Cartwright. She was on the phone, not watching. “I assume that question will become popular.”

Ramirez sighed. “Welcome to Atlanta.”

Alex sat at his desk. The dispatch summaries still waited. He opened the drowning file first. He started rebuilding what had happened before anyone named it. Across the bullpen, Elias returned to his chair near the windows.

Cartwright moved between desks assigning follow-up. Ramirez argued with the printer. On the television, Preston Floyd continued speaking for people who were not in the room. Alex turned the first page. The work had started.

CHAPTER TWO — The River

The call came just after sunrise. Atlanta PD had already secured the riverbank by the time Alex arrived. Yellow tape ran between two trees above the Chattahoochee, and a patrol car blocked the gravel access lot. Ramirez got out beside him.

“That makes three.”

Alex looked toward the river. Marla Benton had been recovered three weeks earlier. Thomas Calder followed ten days later. Both had been bound before entering the water. Now Daniel Kessler had surfaced downstream.

Three recoveries were enough to justify coordinated review without answering what connected them. They started down the access path. The trail was narrow and slick with mud. Exposed roots crossed it in several places, and the slope steepened near the bottom where years of foot traffic had worn away most of the vegetation. A uniformed officer stood near the tape with a notebook hanging loosely from one hand. He recognized Ramirez first.

“Morning.”

“Not yet.”

The officer lifted the tape. Alex ducked beneath it and stepped onto the flattened grass near the bank. The victim lay several yards from the water on a black recovery sheet.

Male.

Late thirties.

Maybe early forties.

Wet clothing clung to him with the heavy shapelessness river recoveries always carried. Mud streaked one side of his face. Water had flattened his hair and darkened his shirt almost black. Wrists bound in front.

Nylon rope.

Alex stopped several feet away. He looked at the body first.

Then the bank.

Then the waterline.

The body had surfaced near the bank rather than midstream. That did not tell him where Kessler entered the water. It told him where the river had stopped carrying him. Two recovery technicians worked around the sheet. A photographer moved through required angles while the medical examiner knelt near Kessler’s legs dictating into a recorder.

The bindings were tight. The wrists had been secured in front. The ankles had been secured separately. A second length connected the two restraint points and limited extension. Ramirez crouched outside the marked evidence area.

“Same configuration.”

Alex nodded.

Marla Benton had been thirty-one.

Accountant.

Lived alone.

Fished occasionally with her brother and two coworkers. Thomas Calder had been fifty-three. Owned a small machine shop.

Divorced.

No criminal history that mattered.

He spent weekends on the river often enough that several people remembered seeing him at the same access points.

Different ages.

Different jobs.

Different lives.

Same river.

Same restraint arrangement.

Alex looked at the knots.

Functional.

Tight.

Nothing decorative.

Nothing unusual enough to identify a particular user.

Commercial nylon rope.

Common diameter.

The kind sold in hardware stores, marine shops, farm-supply stores, big-box retailers, and half the gas stations near recreational water. The medical examiner finished a sequence of photographs and peeled off one glove.

“Time in water?” Alex asked.

Dr. Rebecca Travis looked toward him.

“Less than twelve hours is my working estimate.”

“He hasn’t traveled far?”

“Probably not far after he surfaced. That isn’t the same thing as saying he entered nearby.”

Ramirez nodded toward the water. “Because he could’ve stayed submerged longer.”

“Yes.”

She pointed toward the victim without touching him.

“Skin changes are limited. Livor’s still usable in places. Some slippage starting, but not enough for an extended postmortem interval in the water.”

“Alive when he went in?” Alex asked.

“I’ll be surprised if he wasn’t.”

“Drowning?”

“Likely.”

“Can you give us more than likely?”

“Not standing on a riverbank.”

Ramirez looked toward Alex. “She likes you.”

Travis ignored him.

“The lungs, airway, diatoms if they’re useful, chemistry, everything else waits for autopsy.”

Alex nodded toward the bindings. “Before water?”

“The restraint pattern is consistent with being applied before submersion.”

“Anything suggesting after death?”

“Nothing obvious.”

“Anything suggesting conscious resistance?”

“Too early.”

“Marks?”

“Some pressure effects. I want them cleaned and examined before I characterize them.”

Alex nodded. “Fair.”

Travis looked at him.

“You say that like you expected me to guess.”

“I was hoping you wouldn’t.”

She smiled faintly.

“Then we’ll get along.”

Ramirez looked between them. “I feel excluded.”

“You’ll recover,” Alex said.

Travis returned to the body. Alex moved toward the bank. The river looked ordinary.

Brown-green water.

Slow surface movement near the bend. Debris collected beneath exposed roots. A plastic bottle drifted past without urgency.

Nothing about the water advertised homicide.

A detective from Atlanta PD approached carrying coffee that had gone cold.

Tall.

Mid-forties.

Wrinkled shirt.

Dark circles beneath both eyes.

“Rourke,” he said.

“Harlan.”

“Ramirez.”

Rourke nodded toward the recovery. “Jogger spotted him caught in debris near the bend.”

“Actual recovery location documented before movement?” Alex asked.

“Yes.”

“Photographs?”

“Plenty.”

“Video?”

“Body position before removal, yes.”

“Witness still here?”

“Uniform has him up near the lot.”

“Anything useful?”

“Thought it was a mannequin.”

Ramirez nodded. “They always do.”

Rourke frowned. “What?”

“People always think bodies are mannequins.”

Ramirez glanced toward Alex. “Too early?”

“Yes.”

Rourke continued. “Fire pulled him off the debris and stopped once they saw the bindings.”

“Scene contamination?”

“Minimal for a water recovery. Fire moved him because they couldn’t confirm status from the bank.”

“Anything missing?”

“No wallet visible. No phone. Keys in one pocket. Receipt in another, but it’s saturated.”

“Vehicle?”

“Patrol’s checking nearby lots, ramps, roadside pull-offs.”

“Identification?”

“Prints came back ten minutes before you got here.”

Rourke opened his notebook. “Daniel Kessler. Forty-two. Local address. No warrants.”

Alex looked back toward the body.

Forty-two.

Close enough to the visual estimate.

“What does he do?”

“Warehouse supervisor for a regional distribution company. Night operations.”

“Family?”

“Divorced. Ex-wife in Savannah. No kids.”

“Criminal?”

“Nothing meaningful. Traffic. One old disorderly complaint that never went anywhere.”

“Employment?”

“Same place almost eleven years.”

“Known associates?”

“Neighbor says he worked, fished, kept to himself.”

Ramirez sighed. “Everybody keeps to themselves after they die.”

Rourke looked at him. “That sounded better in your head?”

“Not much.”

The recovery team prepared to move Kessler. Alex stepped farther back. The stretcher bumped over uneven ground as the technicians carried it toward the trail. One adjusted the sheet near Kessler’s shoulder. Another kept the bindings visible until the photographer completed the last series.

Alex watched them disappear over the rise. Then he looked toward the water again.

Three bodies.

Same river.

Same restraint configuration.

End of the free sample

The investigation is just beginning.

Continue the story in UNSOLVED.

Order a paperback directly from the author, or choose paperback or e-book on Amazon.

Copyright © 2026 R. L. Chauncey. All rights reserved.